The Nonconsequencialist

Carol Ploch Nonconsequentialism As a nonconsequentialist, my principle is that an act is just(a) or wrong based on the intention in which it is d hotshot, earlier than the consequences of the act; on that pointfore, in the vivification gravy ride dilemma scenario my finding was to non tug the cd beat out man grapple of the sauceboat. I quantify any new(prenominal) hold universe and weigh that every whizz organism has the same right to invigoration as any other. I also rank for for each one one soulfulness as they are and conceptualise that they add value and worth(predicate) to the world in nigh way which is why they exist. By ironing the four hundred pound man off-key of the boat, I would be treating that individual as a representation to my residue and this is against the Practical Imperative belief that no humans being should be thought of or used however as a means for mortal elses end (Thiroux, Krasemann 2009, p. 51). Many, if non all, of the other nine people on the boat may feel that it would be the best weft to push the largest mortal overboard because they consider the consequence of non doing so, which is the boat sinking and the close of us all. However, I would get to affect myself and the others if this act of sacrificing somebodys conduct on the boat in stupefy out to save others is one that is delightful to put with everyone on board?

Would it be acceptable to always mutilate someone when it could save another persons sprightliness? button anyone off the boat is considered murder, which is not a good act, correspond to the Categorical Imperative, since the meaning of feeling is to live (Thiroux, Krasemann 2009, p. 51). If everyone on the boat pushed someone else off so that their life would be saved, there would be no survivors, which contradicts that living is the meaning of life and therefore, would mess up the Categorical Imperative. My original decision to not push the 400 pound man off the boat has not changed. In fact my original cerebrate for this is that of nonconsequentialism, more specifically, the inspired control Theory. I believe that each one of us would throw off been...If you want to get a full essay, order it on our website: Orderessay

If you want to get a full information about our service, visit our page: How it works.